Main Index
Geometry
Plane Geometry
Geometric constructions
Subject Index
comment on the page
The notion of geometric constructions go back at least to Greek antiquity. The classical constructions are called Euclidean constructions, but they certainly were known prior to Euclid.
The allowed instruments are idealized “mechanisms”, such as [1]
The collapsing compass allows to be opened to a chosen radius and used to drawn the circle, but when it is lifted off the drawing surface, it collapses as the name indicates. This means that no distance can be transferred using it. This contradicts the modern understanding of the compass usage according to which when opened to some aperture and then lifted to another location on the page the compass can be used to transfer the same distance.
Thus the “Euclidean” compass is different from what we understand under the modern compass. Therefore a natural question is whether we can make the same geometric constructions by both compass versions (together with the straightedge which usage underlies the same rules nowadays as before). The answer gives the following Compass Equivalence Theorem:
Theorem: A circle at center and radius can be congruently copied using a straightedge and collapsing compass so that a given point can serve as the center of the copy.
For the solution we can combine first two Euclid’s propositions of Book I . Another solution we get using the steps:
To see this, note that triangles and are congruent by the side-side-side theorem. This implies that angles and at in both triangles are equal. Thus angles and are also equal. By the side-angle-side theorem the triangles and are congruent, i.e. the sides and have the same length.
The straightedge was thought of as having no length markings. This because there is no postulate giving us the ability to measure the lengths. This means that you cannot use the straightedge to extend a segment twice, say, but you can use it to connect a pair of points or to extend the segment given by two distinct points.
The instruments allowed to be used in Euclidean constructions are compass and straightedge. The compass is used to establishes the equidistance, and the straightedge establishes the collinearity. Thus Euclidean geometric constructions are based on these two procedures:
Constructions are understood as a theoretical exercise, where for instance the fact that a line has zero width, and various physical imperfections of the drawing instruments are neglected.
Thus in the spirit of the first three Euclid’s axioms (postulates):
Postulate 1. To draw a straight line from any point to any point.
Postulate 2. To produce a finite straight line continuously in a straight line.
Postulate 3. To describe a circle with any center and radius.
the following constructions are taken for granted:
Construction 1: Given two distinct points , the straight line passing through these two points is considered as being constructed.
Construction 2: Given a point and segment then the circle at and radius is considered as being constructed.
Construction 3: The intersection point of two intersecting lines is considered as being constructed.
Construction 4: Given a circle and a secant line then their intersection points are considered as being constructed.
Construction 5: Given two intersecting circles then their intersection points are considered as being constructed.
Despite the fact that the original famous Euclid’s fifth postulate does not used the notion of parallel lines, Euclid defines this notion in his Definition 23: Parallel straight lines are straight lines which, being in the same plane and being produced indefinitely in both directions, do not meet one another in either direction.
How to construct a straight line through a given point and parallel to a given one not passing trough is described in Proposition 31 of Book I . In practical constructions, however, the parallel lines are constructed using two setquares (having one right angle).
There are three classical Euclidean construction problems (i.e. compass and straightedge constructions) in Greek mathematics which were extremely important in the later development of geometry.:
They are closely linked, and the mathematicians were able to definitely answer these problems (in the negative) only after the Galois theory was developed in 19th century.
Marked rulers (i.e. a straightedge that is notched in two places) and protractors are not allowed in the classical Euclidean constructions. Though the marked ruler is not used in Euclid’s Elements, other Greek geometers used it, for instance Hippocrates of Chios (ca. 430 BC). Pappus reports that Applonius of Perga (ca. 262-190 BC) wrote two books on constructions using marked ruler. Pappus credo was: Whenever a construction is possible by means of compasses and straight edge, more advanced means should not be used.
The constructions using marked ruler were called neusis constructions by ancient Greeks. [2] As it was shown by Archimedes trisection of an angle is possible using a marked ruler:
Given is an angle by the intersection of two lines and which intersect at . Let be the distance between the two notches on the straightedge. Then
Then .
Since the triangle is isosceles, , say.Then for it is an exterior angle to . In the isosceles triangle we have and . Consequently, , as desired.
When the ruler and compass constructions did not offer a solution then also other types of construction elements were accepted, for instance
[1] | Toussaint, G. T. (1993). A new look at Euclid’s second proposition. The Mathematical Intelligencer, 15(3), 12-23. |
[2] | Hartshorne, R. (2000). Geometry: Euclid and Beyond. Springer. |
Cite this web-page as:
Štefan Porubský: Euclidean Constructions.